The MarketplaceFamily run. Florida made.
Rich, creamy, and full of personality. Every small batch starts with real butter and real cream, then makes room for the flavors that turn one square into a favorite.
The good kind of homemade feeling
Handmade fudge should feel like a treat before the first bite. It has a soft, rich texture, the kind that invites you to pause for a minute, then reach for a second square because one flavor is never quite enough. At The Marketplace Fudge and More, the work begins with real butter, real cream, and the care of making in small batches.
That foundation matters, but it is not where the fun stops. The family has been creating fudge since 2012 and has dreamed up more than 300 flavors. Some are the familiar favorites people return to again and again. Others lean into cookies, coffee, citrus, fruit, coconut, caramel, turtles, and playful desserts. The selection changes, so there is always a reason to look for a new favorite beside an old reliable one.
Whether you are choosing a treat for yourself, something to share after dinner, or a gift that feels more personal than a standard box of candy, the best place to start is the flavor that sounds good now. The next choice can be the surprise.
Choose your kind of favorite
Start with the experience you want, then let the current selection guide the rest.
Chocolate, peanut butter, caramel, cookies, and creamy favorites are a lovely place to begin when you know exactly what you are craving. A familiar flavor lets the small-batch texture do the talking, and it gives every other choice in the box an easy companion.
Browse current flavorsA bright citrus note, a coffee-inspired piece, a turtle with caramel and crunch, or a dessert-style flavor can make a simple treat feel like a tiny discovery. The point is not to choose the most unusual name. It is to find the one you will still be thinking about later.
Find your flavor styleWhen one flavor will not do, choose four fudge or turtle treats for a mix that fits your table, your mood, or the person you are giving to. Begin with one sure thing, then give yourself room for a few good surprises.
Build your four-treat box
A little variety goes a long way
For a first handmade-fudge order, pair two flavors you already trust with two that catch your eye. A chocolate or peanut-butter choice gives the box a comforting center. Caramel, cookie, coffee, fruit, citrus, or coconut can bring contrast. A turtle adds a little crunch and makes a good option for the person who loves chocolate and caramel together.
When the box is for a group, there is no need to find one flavor everyone agrees on. A mix works better. Put a classic beside something creamy or nutty, add a brighter choice, then finish with a playful piece. Everyone gets a way in, and the shared comparison of favorites becomes part of the experience.
For a gift, choose around the person rather than the occasion. Start with the flavor they already order, then add one choice that feels a little more like them. That small bit of attention is what makes a fudge box feel considered.
Explore fudge gift boxesSmall batch, big imagination
Handmade does not have to mean complicated. It means there is room for the little details that make a piece of fudge feel more satisfying: a rich, creamy base, a flavor that comes through clearly, and an assortment that does not taste the same from one square to the next. It is the difference between grabbing something sweet and choosing a treat you are genuinely looking forward to.
The current shop is the best guide to what is ready today. It shows the live flavor selection, product details, options, availability, and price. Start there when you have a particular craving. If you would rather explore, the Fudge Guide to choosing flavors can help you compare familiar picks with the kinds of treats that make a box feel new.
For an easy four-treat mix, use Build a Box. Each item is a quarter pound, so four choices make a full pound of fudge or turtle treats. The Build a Box price is $26.95, a $1.05 saving compared with purchasing four $7 treats separately. It is a straightforward way to choose a little variety without turning the decision into a project.
If ingredients are important for you or the person receiving the fudge, take a moment to review the live product details before ordering. Fudge is made with dairy, and individual flavors may include peanuts, tree nuts, cookies, or other ingredients that matter for an allergy. For a specific question, the family is available through the contact page.
Frequently asked questions
Handmade fudge begins with careful small-batch preparation and ingredients chosen for a rich, creamy bite. At The Marketplace Fudge and More, real butter and real cream are the foundation, then each batch gets its own personality from the flavor folded in.
The current selection changes. You may find familiar chocolate, peanut butter, caramel, cookies, coffee, fruit, citrus, coconut, turtle treats, and playful dessert-inspired flavors. Browse the live shop to see what is ready today.
Yes. Build a Box lets you choose four fudge or turtle treats, so you can start with favorites and add a few new flavors that sound worth discovering.
The Marketplace Fudge and More makes small-batch fudge in Florida. The family has been creating flavors since 2012, with more than 300 flavors dreamed up along the way.
Ready for a good treat?
Browse the current flavors, make a four-treat box, and leave room for a new favorite.