The MarketplaceFour treats, your way
Pick a few old favorites, add one you have never tried, and make room for a little surprise. A four-treat sampler is the easiest way to taste more of what makes small-batch fudge so much fun.
Taste beyond the usual
A fudge sampler is for the person who does not want to settle on just one flavor. It is a chance to start with a familiar square, try a flavor that sounds too interesting to pass up, and find the treat you will think about after the last bite. At The Marketplace Fudge and More, every choice starts with rich fudge made in small batches with real butter and real cream, then gets its own personality from the flavors folded in.
The Build a Box option gives you four fudge or turtle treats to make your own. Choose all classics if that is what you love. Mix chocolate, peanut butter, caramel, coffee, cookies, fruit, citrus, coconut, or dessert-inspired flavors if you are in the mood to explore. The current selection changes, which means there is always a good reason to come back and see what is waiting in the case.
The family has dreamed up more than 300 flavors since 2012. That is plenty of experience behind a simple idea: a sweet treat should feel a little more personal than picking the same box everyone else brings home. A sampler makes that easy without turning the choice into homework.
A simple way to choose
There is no wrong mix. These three starting points make it easier to create a box that feels balanced, generous, and genuinely yours.
Choose the flavors you already reach for, such as chocolate, peanut butter, caramel, or cookies and cream. Then make the fourth treat a close cousin, like a turtle or a coffee-forward option, for a box that feels familiar but never flat.
See today’s flavors →Start with one rich chocolate choice, add a creamy or nutty favorite, bring in something bright or fruity, and finish with a playful dessert-inspired flavor. Each piece changes the next one, which is exactly what makes a sampler worth sharing.
Choose four treats →Choosing for someone else? Begin with the flavors they would recognize first, then add one surprise. A four-treat sampler feels thoughtful for a host, a birthday, a thank-you, or the person who is impossible to shop for.
Explore fudge gift ideas →
Start with four
A great sampler has contrast. A deep chocolate flavor feels even richer next to something bright. A caramel or peanut butter treat brings an easy, creamy middle. A cookie, coffee, coconut, fruit, or citrus pick gives the whole box a new direction. You do not need to predict the one perfect flavor. You only need a few good places to begin.
That is why four treats work so well. There is room for the comfort choice, the curious choice, and the flavor that becomes the surprise favorite. Enjoy them one at a time, put them out after dinner, or let everyone at the table call dibs before the box is empty.
Build a four-treat boxSmall-batch makes a difference
A sampler should not feel like a handful of leftovers. Each square and turtle treat is made to be enjoyed on its own, whether you stay with a tried-and-true favorite or bring home something completely new. Small batches keep the focus where it belongs: on a rich, creamy bite and the fun of seeing which flavor wins you over.
If you are new to the shop, the current product details are the right place to check ingredients and flavor notes before you choose. Fudge is made with dairy, and individual flavors may include peanuts, tree nuts, cookies, or other ingredients that matter for an allergy. When in doubt, take a look at the live listing or contact the family before ordering.
Want a little help narrowing the field? The Fudge Guide to choosing flavors gives you an easy way to think about classics, adventurous picks, and combinations that work well together. Then come back to build the four-treat mix that sounds most like you.
A treat worth passing around
A sampler is as flexible as the reason you ordered it. Keep it for a movie night. Set it out after dinner when friends come by. Bring it to someone who deserves more than a generic card. Four treats are enough to make the moment feel special, but not so much that choosing gets complicated.
For a more gift-focused mix, start with familiar flavors and add one cheerful wildcard. For a household full of different tastes, choose a chocolate, a nutty or caramel option, a cookie or coffee flavor, and a bright fruit or citrus pick. If the box disappears quickly, that only tells you what to choose more of next time.
Ready to see what is available? Browse the current selection, build your own four-treat box, and let the next favorite reveal itself.
Frequently asked questions
A sampler is simply a chance to enjoy more than one flavor in the same order. Build a Box starts with four fudge or turtle treats, so you can keep it classic, try something unexpected, or do a little of both.
Yes. Use Build a Box to choose the four treats that sound best to you from the current selection. Available flavors change, so the live product page is the best place to see what is ready now.
Start with one familiar favorite, add a second creamy or caramel-forward option, then choose one bright, fruity, coffee, cookie, or dessert-inspired flavor. A turtle treat is an easy way to bring in chocolate, caramel, and crunch.
It can be a thoughtful choice for anyone who enjoys trying a few things. If you are choosing for someone else, begin with familiar flavors and add one fun surprise. For more gift-focused ideas, visit the fudge gift boxes page.
Ready when you are
Choose the mix that sounds good now, then make room for the one that surprises you.