The MarketplaceFamily run. Florida made.
Choose handmade fudge with real butter, real cream, and a whole lot more personality than the candy aisle. Browse the current flavors, find a classic, and bring home something unexpected.
A better kind of sweet order
Buying fudge online should feel like stepping up to a good candy counter, not scrolling through a row of identical boxes. At The Marketplace Fudge and More, every batch begins with the same small-batch care, then gets its character from the flavors folded in. Some days that means deep chocolate, creamy peanut butter, caramel, coffee, or cookies and cream. Other days, it means citrus, Key Lime, birthday cake, or a combination that sounds like it should not work until the first bite proves otherwise.
The family has been making fudge since 2012 and has dreamed up more than 300 flavors along the way. That gives you a simple choice when you order: stay with the familiar, mix in a surprise, or do both. Browse what is available now, then choose the treats that fit your mood, your table, or the person you have in mind.
A good order does not have to be complicated. One rich chocolate choice gives the box an easy center. A peanut butter, caramel, coffee, or cookie flavor adds a second familiar lane. Then a fruit, citrus, coconut, or dessert-inspired flavor changes the conversation. That is enough variety for most people to find a favorite, without turning the choice into a project.
Find your way in
Whether the order is for you, a gift, or a table full of people, begin with the route that makes choosing feel easy.
Take the full tour when you want to see what is in the case right now. Start with the flavors you already love, then scan for a second or third choice that gives the order a little contrast. Chocolate, caramel, peanut butter, fruit, coffee, coconut, cookies, and turtles all make different kinds of good first picks.
Shop all current fudgeWant a simple assortment without settling for a mystery mix? Choose four fudge or turtle treats and make the box your own. It is an easy way to try a few flavors, share with someone else, or give a gift that feels like you chose it on purpose.
Build your own boxWhen the order is headed to a birthday, thank-you, host, or holiday table, variety does the work. Use a familiar flavor as the anchor, add a creamy or nutty choice, then finish with one bright or playful surprise. The result feels generous without being hard to choose.
Explore fudge gift boxes
A little help choosing
For the chocolate person: begin with a classic chocolate flavor, then add a caramel, coconut, walnut, sea salt, or peanut butter companion. It keeps the box rich while giving every piece its own mood.
For the person who always tries dessert first: look for a flavor that leans into cookies, birthday cake, cheesecake, coffee, or another favorite treat. These are the pieces that make an assortment feel personal instead of generic.
For someone who likes a bright surprise: bring in a fruit or citrus-inspired flavor. A lively piece can lift a box full of chocolate and caramel, especially when you are sharing with people who do not all reach for the same thing.
For a first order: choose two dependable favorites and two that make you curious. You get the comfort of a sure thing, plus a reason to come back and compare notes after the first few bites.
There is no single right combination. An order for one person can lean into the flavors they never get tired of. An order for a household or office can spread out across familiar chocolate, creamy peanut butter, caramel, and one bright wildcard. Start with the people who will enjoy it, not a pre-set assortment, and the box is far more likely to disappear quickly.
See the current selectionSmall batch, not same old
There is a reason a small-batch treat feels different from a box grabbed at the register. Fudge is meant to be rich, creamy, and satisfying in a way that lets one square feel like a proper dessert. Real butter and real cream are part of that foundation. The rest is the fun of choosing flavors with enough personality to make people ask for another piece before they have finished the first.
That is also why a mixed order works so well. One flavor can be smooth and familiar. Another can bring crunch, caramel, cookies, coffee, fruit, or a little extra salt. The variety gives a family movie night, a desk drawer, a visit with friends, or an unexpected gift more than one small moment to enjoy.
When you are buying for a group, do not try to guess one universal favorite. Give people a few different ways in. A straightforward chocolate flavor is easy for traditionalists. A turtle or nutty selection brings texture. A fruit, citrus, or dessert-inspired piece gives the adventurous person something to claim first. A mix with that kind of range feels thoughtful because every choice has a place.
Fudge also makes the kind of treat that does not need a formal occasion. Keep a few pieces for an after-dinner bite, bring a box to a weekend get-together, or choose an assortment that can be opened when a friend stops by. When the moment calls for something bigger, the shop also has fudge turtles, shareable boards, dipped treats, and fudge pies to explore.
The current selection changes, which is part of the appeal. Browse before ordering so you can see the latest choices and product details. When you find the flavors that sound right, add them to your cart and check out directly through the store. For a special request, a larger occasion, or help with an order, the family is easy to reach through the contact page.
Before you order
Fudge is made with dairy, and individual flavors may include peanuts, tree nuts, cookies, or other ingredients that matter for an allergy. Always review the current product details for the flavor you are considering. When the order is for someone with an allergy or another specific ingredient concern, contact the family before placing it.
For the best experience, let the current product page guide the decision. It is the right place to confirm the flavor, ingredients, options, availability, and price for the treat you want today.
That quick check keeps the order focused on the flavors everyone can enjoy, and makes a gift or shared box easier to choose with confidence.
Frequently asked questions
Yes. Browse the current selection, choose the flavors that sound good, and add them to your cart. The online store shows the available options and current prices before checkout.
Yes. Build a Box lets you choose four fudge or turtle treats for an assortment that feels personal, whether you are sharing it, sending a gift, or trying a few new favorites yourself.
The selection changes, with choices ranging from chocolate, peanut butter, caramel, cookies, coffee, fruit, and citrus flavors to playful dessert-inspired creations. Browse the current shop for what is available today.
Review the current product details and contact the family before ordering. Fudge is made with dairy, and individual flavors may include peanuts, tree nuts, cookies, or other ingredients that matter for an allergy.
Ready for something sweet?
Start with the flavors you know, then add the one that makes the box memorable.